Omein in beginning of Kaddish, after 'shemei rabboh'

יותר
11 נוב 2009 14:30 #1486 מאת rallisw
When did the minhog of answering Omein after the phrase, "Yisgadal v'yiskadash shmei rabboh" begin? Should one do so, since it is not mentioned in most siddurim?

Rallis

Minhag Avoseinu Torah Hee!

Please התחברות to join the conversation.

יותר
13 נוב 2009 16:32 #1491 מאת Michael
There is no doubt one should answer Omen after "Shmei Rabbo". This is brought in the Roke'ach and the Rambam. There is an argument about Omen after Brich Hu, and Minhag Ashkenaz is against it. There also is a question, according to Minhag Sepharad that say "Veyatsmach etc. Meshichei" if Omen should be said after that, (The גרי"ז סולובייציק held that since the Rambam doesn't mention Omen there - even those who say these words shouldn't say Omen), but there is no argument about Omen after "Shemi Rabbo".

Michael FRBSH

Please התחברות to join the conversation.

יותר
15 נוב 2009 02:22 #1494 מאת rallisw

Michael wrote: There is no doubt one should answer Omen after "Shmei Rabbo".

Why is it not printed in most Nusach Ashkenaz Siddurim?

Rallis

Minhag Avoseinu Torah Hee!

Please התחברות to join the conversation.

Powered by פורום קוננה