Hoshanos hanhogos al pi minhag Ashkenaz
- Daniel
- מחבר נושא
- מנותק
פחות
יותר
- הודעות 221
- תודות התקבלו: 2
06 אוק 2009 21:28 #1453
מאת Daniel
Hoshanos hanhogos al pi minhag Ashkenaz נוצר על ידי Daniel
How should one recite Hoshanos at non-Yekke Minyanim? Should one say their nusach? Say our Nusach quietly? When saying the actual paragraph for the day, does one add the word Hoshana before and after each phrase (like most shuls seem to do it), or should you read the text as it is written?
Daniel
Daniel
Please התחברות to join the conversation.
- Michael
- מנותק
08 אוק 2009 15:46 #1454
מאת Michael
תגובה מMichael בדיון Hoshanos hanhogos al pi minhag Ashkenaz
Our minhag is to say Hoshano only seven times - Once at the beginning, then after Lemancho Elokeinu, after Lemancho Boreinu, after Lemancho Go'aleinu and after Lemancho Dorsheinu, and two more times at the end of the Alphabetical Techino.
The order of the Alphabetical Techinos is:
אערוך שועי, א-ל למושעות, אום אני חומה, אבן שתיה, אדמה מארר
In case one davens in a shul following a different Minhag, Moreinu Harav Gans told me the important thing is that a techino is said walking around the Bimah (Almemar), therefore one should say the Techino said locally. (In case he davens the next day in a shul following MA, it may result that he says the same Techino twice, or omits one of the Techinos, but there's no harm in that). But he added that there is no need to say Hoshano with the Tzibbur all the times they say it, and he can say 7 times only like it would be done by MA.
Michael
The order of the Alphabetical Techinos is:
אערוך שועי, א-ל למושעות, אום אני חומה, אבן שתיה, אדמה מארר
In case one davens in a shul following a different Minhag, Moreinu Harav Gans told me the important thing is that a techino is said walking around the Bimah (Almemar), therefore one should say the Techino said locally. (In case he davens the next day in a shul following MA, it may result that he says the same Techino twice, or omits one of the Techinos, but there's no harm in that). But he added that there is no need to say Hoshano with the Tzibbur all the times they say it, and he can say 7 times only like it would be done by MA.
Michael
Please התחברות to join the conversation.