Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me
  • Page:
  • 1

TOPIC: Additional Tefilos in Shmoneh Esrei

Additional Tefilos in Shmoneh Esrei 05 Jun 2010 19:28 #1764

  • SBS
  • Posts: 112
In many siddurim there are 2 bakoshos that are printed for one to say at the end of Shema Koleinu. One is for Kaporoh and the other for Parnosoh. What is the origin of these and were they said in Ashkenaz and if so where?


The administrator has disabled public write access.

Additional Tefilos in Shmoneh Esrei 18 Jun 2010 15:01 #1773

  • Michael
  • Posts: 1038
  • Thank you received 42
Rav Yakov Emden was against adding texts of tefilloh to Shema Koleinu, saying that in Shema Koleinu one should add his own request and not follow a text, since if Chazal would think any specific text should be added - they would add it themselves.

In the Siddurim before the time of R' Wolf Heidenheim we don't find these tefillos.

The Nusach we have for the Vidui was written by Kitzur Sheloh (Rav Yechiel Michel Epstein, at the 18th Century), and is similar to a nusach printed in Sharei Tziyon (Kabbalic Tefillos written about 100 years beforehand).
Siddur Tseloso De'Avrohom (by the Tschechnover Rebbe before the Holocaust) writes:
הנה נדפס בסידורים האחרונים להתוודות בשומע תפילה ויש לזה מקור בזוהר שיחיד יפרש חטאו בשו"ת וכן הוא בסידור האר"י שצריך להתוודות שם, אבל יש שמפקפים שהוא נגד דינא דגמ' דאדם שואל צרכיו בשומע תפילה ואם בא לומר כסדר וידוי של יום כיפור לאחר תפילתו אומר, משמע שלאחר תפילתו אומר סדר וידוי של יום כיפור ולא באמצע תפילתו

Michael FRBSH
The administrator has disabled public write access.
  • Page:
  • 1