Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me
  • Page:
  • 1

TOPIC: Pronunciation Differences Between Komatz & Patach

Pronunciation Differences Between Komatz & Patach 05 אוג' 2011 15:20 #2022

  • rallisw
  • מנותקים
  • Posts: 245
In או"ח הלכות תפילין ס' ז the ש"ע notes a difference a פתח and קמץ. How come the Sephardic pronunciation has changed over the centuries, whereas the Ashkenazic pronunciation, at least of these two vowels, has stayed true?

Rallis
Minhag Avoseinu Torah Hee!
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Pronunciation Differences Between Komatz & Patach 16 ספט' 2011 12:21 #2035

  • Michael
  • מנותקים
  • Posts: 1038
  • Thank you received 42
That is definitely a major issue with the Sephardic pronunciation. R' Yaakov Emden was very much opposed to the Sephardic pronunciation for this reason, and he even said "Boruch Shelo Aso'ani Sepharadi Benivi (in my pronunciation)". See עמודי שמים, אלטונא תק"ה, דף ד.

Some Tunisian Medakdekim claim there is a difference in the Sephardic pronunciation between the Patach and Kamatz.
But that is something that is very hard to hear or be sure it exists, and really should be discussed in a Minhag Sepharad forum and not in a Minhag Ashkenaz forum.

Michael FRBSH
The administrator has disabled public write access.
  • Page:
  • 1